American Idol - Neil Diamond week! - who goes home tonite?

oh my gosh--- i actually phoned in some votes for Syesha (after i voted 50 times for David Cook of course). i can't even believe it myself. where has this girl been hiding? she looked so good this week and she sounded great. of course i am betting (sadly) that she will go home this week based on the fact that this is more a popularity contest than anything else. josh was still determined to vote for Jason, no matter how sucky he was last night. Jason really should go. Brooke was barely more tolerable. the worst of the evening i have to say was David Archuleta----he BUTCHERED one of my favorite Neil Diamond songs (sweet caroline)--- i was so sure the judges were going to be critical, but no-- they LOVED it. and i thought his rendition of "America" was pathetic. why they want him to win the whole thing is beyond me! the highlight of the evening was watching an obviously drunk (or drugged) Paula Abdul criticizing a performance that hadnt even happened yet! classic!